Ratan Tata unveiled the Nano at the Delhi Auto Expo on January 10, 2008. The Tata Nano is the $2,500 car that has been designed and built in India at the hands of more than 500 people from around the world. I was reading the english Times Online write up about the Nano and enjoyed all the comments left on the article. One of them was particularly interesting to me as it captured my opinion of this announcement almost perfectly.
“$2500 cars already exist, they are called “used cars”. Option A, new tin can with 33hp, Option B 5-8 year old real car, like a Carolla or Civic or Sentra. Which will last longer, be safer, and look better?
Maybe one positive of this car will be that it will drive used car prices down.”
~Mike S, Dallas
The idea of a car costing only $2,500 is not new. Plenty of depreciated vehicles fall into this price range, and lots of those used vehicles are not aluminum bubbles that top out at 65mph. I do disagree with Mike from Dallas that this car will drive used car prices down, and a few other ideas come to mind when I think about how the Tata Nano might impact the American market.
- it will not
- the Nano is not coming to America
- it is not allowed to come to America because of environmental and safety requirements
- the Nano is not of higher quality than $2,500 used cars in America
- driving in India is safer than driving in America†
- why do all highly efficient vehicles look like cartoon bubble cars
†Roughly 85,000 people are killed each year in India as the result of a car crash, and less than 50,000 killed similarly in America. The population of India is 3.75 times that of the US, but the number of people killed in car crashes is only about 2 times that in the US.